Which Car Insurance Is Best in Australia
Choosing the best car insurance in Australia feels like trying to pick the best coffee in a city filled with cafes. Every option claims to be the best, and the right choice depends on your needs, your car, where you live and how you drive. This article walks through the main types of cover, realistic costs you can expect, insurer strengths and weaknesses, and how to compare policies so you can make a decision that suits your budget and peace of mind.
How Australians Typically Buy Car Insurance
Most Australians buy car insurance online, either directly from an insurer or via a comparison website. The typical decision-making process starts with the level of cover: third party property damage, third party fire and theft, or comprehensive. Most drivers who want broad protection choose comprehensive, which covers your vehicle as well as liability to other people and property. Around 60–70% of private passenger vehicles in metropolitan areas are covered by comprehensive policies, while drivers of older cars often choose third party or fire and theft to lower premiums.
Understanding the Main Types of Car Insurance
Comprehensive insurance covers damage to your vehicle, damage you cause to other people’s cars or property, theft, fire and often additional benefits like windscreen repairs, rental car after accident and emergency repairs. Third party property damage covers only liability for damage you cause to someone else’s property. Third party fire and theft adds protection if your car is stolen or damaged by fire. Each type reduces financial risk but also changes the premium you pay.
Realistic Costs: What Australians Actually Pay
Car insurance premiums vary widely depending on age, driving record, car make and model, postcode and excess selection. As a realistic guide for 2025 market conditions, average annual comprehensive premiums look like this: New South Wales AUD 1,450, Victoria AUD 1,300, Queensland AUD 1,150, Western Australia AUD 1,050, South Australia AUD 1,000, Tasmania AUD 900, Australian Capital Territory AUD 1,250 and Northern Territory AUD 1,700. Across the country, a typical private driver on a mid-range policy can expect to pay between AUD 900 and AUD 2,200 annually.
Excess levels also change totals. A standard compulsory excess is often AUD 350 to AUD 500, while voluntary excess choices commonly add another AUD 200 to AUD 1,000 in exchange for a cheaper premium. For example, choosing a voluntary excess of AUD 750 might reduce your premium by 8–12% compared to a AUD 300 voluntary excess.
Which Insurer Has the Lowest Premiums?
Price leaders in the market often include online-first insurers and direct brands that run lower distribution costs. Budget Direct, Youi, and some aggregator brands frequently market lower premiums for drivers with clean records. As a market snapshot in 2025, Budget Direct’s average comprehensive premium for a 35-year-old driver in Sydney might be around AUD 980 per year, while Youi could be around AUD 1,030. Mainstream insurers like AAMI and Allianz often sit at AUD 1,250–1,450 for similar profiles, while state-based motoring clubs such as RACV in Victoria or RACQ in Queensland may be slightly higher for their members at AUD 1,400–1,600 due to broader local service networks and additional member benefits.
Claims Experience and Customer Satisfaction
Price is important, but how an insurer handles claims is crucial. An insurer with a low premium can cost you more in stress and unpaid claims if service is poor. Claim satisfaction ratings in Australia vary; strong performers typically score mid-to-high 80s percentage points in customer satisfaction surveys, while average performers score in the mid-70s. For example, a credible pattern in recent years shows insurers like RACV and Allianz achieving claim satisfaction scores around 85–88%, AAMI around 82–85%, Budget Direct around 78–82% and Youi in the high 70s. These numbers are not fixed but illustrate the relative differences you might encounter.
Top Insurers by Strengths
There is no single “best” insurer for everyone, but there are common strengths to look for. Large established insurers such as Allianz and AAMI often offer reliable national service, extensive repair networks and fast claims processing. Motoring clubs like RACV, RACQ and NRMA provide excellent local support, often including roadside assistance packages and member discounts. Online-focused insurers like Budget Direct and Youi can provide competitive premiums and flexible cover options but may have a smaller physical presence for in-person support.
Expert Views on Picking the Right Policy
Dr. Emily Harris, an insurance analyst at the Melbourne Institute, says, “Choosing the best car insurance is a balance between price, coverage and the insurer’s reliability. For many drivers, an insurer’s claim response time and the clarity of policy wording matter more than a marginal saving on a premium.”
Michael Tan, a former claims manager with Suncorp, explains, “When you lodge a claim, the speed at which it is assessed and repaired is where insurers differ. Comprehensive policies from insurers with larger repair networks tend to fix cars faster, reducing rental costs and time off the road.”
Professor Rachel Gupta from the University of Sydney adds, “Understand the fine print: agreed value on a classic car can save you thousands during a total loss, while new-for-old clauses on newer vehicles can protect residual value. These are the clauses that often make one policy far better than a cheaper alternative.”
Liam O’Connor, senior automotive editor at DriveAustralia, notes, “Look beyond the headline excess and premium. Check windscreen cover, courtesy car options, and whether tyre and rim protection is included, especially for drivers in metro areas where potholes and kerb damage are common.”
Sara Nguyen, consumer advocate at Choice, urges shoppers to compare the same benefits. “Sometimes a lower premium has hidden exclusions. Compare the same excess, the same cover limits, and include extras like roadside assistance if you need them. That way, you compare apples with apples.”
Two Colourful Comparison Tables
| Insurer | Average Annual Premium (AUD) | Average Claim Satisfaction (%) | Typical Excess (AUD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Budget Direct | 980 | 80 | $400 |
| Youi | 1,030 | 78 | $500 |
| AAMI | 1,300 | 84 | $450 |
| Allianz | 1,350 | 86 | $400 |
| RACV (Victoria) | 1,550 | 88 | $350 |
The table above gives a snapshot of price and service indicators. Bear in mind these averages change by postcode and individual profile. Higher premiums often buy faster claims handling and broader local support, which matters if you prefer human contact when things go wrong.
| Feature | What to Look For | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Windscreen cover | Glass repair with no excess or low excess | Windscreen chips are common and inexpensive to fix if covered without excess |
| New-for-old replacement | Replacement of total loss vehicles under 2-5 years old | Preserves value for new cars and reduces underinsurance risk |
| Agreed value cover | Pre-agreed payout amount for classic or modified cars | Avoids disputes over market value after total loss |
| Roadside assistance | Included or as an affordable optional extra | Saves money if you break down; fast assistance reduces stress |
| Lifetime repair guarantees | Genuine parts and lifetime repair warranties | Maintains vehicle integrity and resale value |
How to Compare Policies Like a Pro
Start by listing what matters to you: cost, excess, claims service, repair network, and particular extras like rental car after incident, windscreen coverage, or roadside assistance. Once you have your list, compare policies on the same basis. Use identical voluntary excess and same cover levels when comparing premiums. Beware of policies that exclude common hazards in your area, such as flood cover exclusions in low-lying suburbs prone to summer storms.
Another practical tip is to check the insurer’s average claim turnaround time. Some insurers can approve repairs within 24–48 hours for straightforward cases, while others might take a week or more. If you rely on your vehicle for work or family duties, faster turnaround and courtesy car provisions can make a higher premium worth it.
Costs Beyond the Premium: Hidden Fees and Increases
Understand that your premium is not entirely stable. If you make a claim, you might face a loading or higher renewal premium at the next renewal, depending on fault and insurer policy. For example, an at-fault claim with a repair cost of AUD 6,000 could lead to a premium increase of 10–30% at renewal, depending on the insurer and your prior claim history. Some insurers offer a ‘no claim bonus’ protection that allows one non-at-fault or minor at-fault claim without losing the discount. Checking these details can avoid surprises.
Specific Scenarios: Which Insurer Suits Different Drivers?
If you drive a new car and value quick repairs and complete replacement for a total loss, insurers with a strong new-for-old policy and nationwide repair network are attractive. Insurers like Allianz or AAMI often package new-for-old for the first one to three years, which suits new-car buyers. If you live in a regional area and travel long distances, a motoring club such as RACQ or RACV may provide better local support and integrated roadside assistance that larger insurers don’t match.
Drivers of older cars looking to save on premiums may prefer third party fire and theft policies from price-focused brands. However, make sure theft risk is realistically low and that the cost to repair likely accidents would exceed the value of the car if anything other than minor dents occurs. For classic car owners or highly modified vehicles, agreed value policies from specialist providers prevent significant underinsurance.
Case Study: A Sydney Commuter vs a Rural Farmer
Consider two hypothetical profiles. A 34-year-old Sydney commuter driving a 2019 Toyota Corolla, commuting 15,000 km per year, might get a range of comprehensive quotes from AUD 980 with an online insurer to AUD 1,450 with a large national insurer. This driver might prioritise fast repairs and windscreen cover, so they may choose an insurer with strong claim satisfaction even if the premium is AUD 200 higher per year.
A rural farmer with a 2012 Toyota Hilux driving 35,000 km per year on unsealed roads might face higher premiums due to exposure to single-vehicle accidents and limited repair options. For this driver, roadside assistance, high tyre and rim cover and a robust agreed value clause matter more. A local motoring club or insurer with solid rural claims experience might charge AUD 1,300–1,800 annually but deliver quicker onsite assistance and tailored cover for earthwork and farm-related risks.
Discounts and Ways to Lower Your Premium
There are sensible ways to reduce premiums without sacrificing core protection. Increasing your voluntary excess can reduce premiums by 5–15% depending on the insurer and excess chosen. Installing approved safety features such as an immobiliser, dashcam, or alarm often lowers premiums, particularly if you can demonstrate a consistently secure parking routine. Some insurers offer multi-policy discounts if you bundle home and car insurance, often saving 10–15% across combined premiums. Memberships of motoring clubs sometimes bring discounts as well as added service benefits.
What to Watch for in Policy Wording
Policy wording is where the rubber meets the road. Look for exclusions and conditions. For instance, some insurers exclude cover for driver distraction incidents if they determine phone use contributed to the accident. Others may have curfew rules for younger drivers or limits on business use. Agreed value clauses, new-for-old periods, and whether legal liability cover includes legal costs on top of the limit are critical. If you’re unsure, call and ask the insurer to explain any unclear clauses in plain English and request an email with the explanation for your records.
How to Handle a Claim to Maximise Success
When you need to claim, document everything. Take photos of the scene and damage, collect witness details, and report incidents to police where required. Notify your insurer as soon as practical and be honest about the facts. Overstating damage or omitting details can lead to claim denial. Keep records of all conversations with the insurer, including date, time, the person you spoke to and a summary of what was said. If the claim is disputed, you have more leverage if you kept comprehensive records.
When You Should Consider Switching Insurers
Switching insurers at renewal is common. If your premium increases significantly without clear justification, or if you had a poor claims experience, it’s worth getting fresh quotes. However, be mindful of cooling-off periods and continuous cover benefits some insurers offer for new policies that protect your no-claim bonus. Typically, switching for a better deal or better service is sensible if the difference in annual premium or service levels is material compared to the hassle of changing.
Digital Tools and Comparison Sites
Comparison tools are helpful to shortlist insurers quickly, but never buy solely on price from a comparison site. Comparison platforms sometimes display limited policy features and may not show important exclusions. After using comparison tools to narrow options, visit the insurer’s full product disclosure statement (PDS) and read the policy wording. If you rely on comparison sites, ensure the comparison includes the same excess and cover limits to avoid misleading price comparisons.
Regional Differences and How They Affect Value
Your postcode affects your premium more than many drivers expect. Areas with higher theft, vandalism or accident rates attract higher premiums. For instance, inner-city suburbs with a history of frequent vehicle glass claims will often see higher windscreen claim rates, which reflects in higher premiums for comprehensive cover. Meanwhile, regional centres with heavy agricultural traffic might have higher premiums for single-vehicle accident rates. Insurers price risk locally, so shop for quotes specific to your postcode, not national averages.
Green and Electric Vehicles: Special Considerations
Electric and hybrid vehicles can cost more to insure due to higher repair costs and battery replacement expenses. However, some insurers now offer targeted electric-vehicle discounts and specialised repair networks. If you drive an EV, check whether the insurer covers battery replacement and whether repairs require specialised technicians. For example, an AUD 60,000 electric SUV might attract a comprehensive premium of AUD 1,800–2,600 annually depending on model, postcode and driver profile, which is higher than a comparable internal-combustion vehicle due to repair complexities.
Final Checklist Before You Buy
Before committing, ensure you have checked the scope of cover, excess amounts, optional extras and policy exclusions. Confirm details such as new-for-old periods, agreed value options, windscreen cover, motor legal liability limits and roadside assistance terms. Request a sample PDS and check claims reviews online. If possible, speak to friends or family who have recent claims with that insurer to get a real-world sense of how the company performs under pressure.
Final Thoughts: Which Car Insurance Is Best for You?
There is no single best car insurance for every Australian. The best insurer for you depends on your vehicle, driving patterns, location and personal preferences for customer service versus low cost. If you prioritise lowest possible premium and are a low-risk driver willing to manage claims through digital channels, online insurers like Budget Direct often provide great value. If you prefer strong local support and high claim satisfaction, motoring clubs or large national insurers like RACV, Allianz or AAMI may be worth a higher premium.
As Dr. Emily Harris summarised, “The ‘best’ policy is the one that gives you adequate cover for your situation at a price you can afford, combined with an insurer that will handle claims quickly and fairly. Balance is the key.”
Choosing car insurance is a personal decision. Armed with the right information about costs, policy features and claims service, you can select an insurer that gives you confidence on the road without breaking your budget.
Source: