on Business Insurance Uncategorized

Volunteer Directors and Liability: Coverage Nuances in Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance for Nonprofits

Directors and Officers (D&O) liability insurance is a cornerstone of risk management for U.S. nonprofits, charities, and NGOs that rely heavily on volunteer leadership. Volunteer directors can face real legal exposures — from donor disputes to regulatory investigations — and nonprofits must understand how standard D&O policies treat volunteers and what gaps commonly arise.

This article focuses on U.S. nonprofits (with examples tied to New York, California and Illinois), explains coverage nuances for volunteer directors, compares market options and pricing, and gives practical steps boards can take to secure affordable, protective D&O terms.

Why volunteers need protection — short legal context

  • Volunteer directors owe fiduciary duties (duty of care, loyalty, obedience) under state law. States such as New York, California and Illinois enforce these duties and allow litigation by donors, regulators or creditors.
  • The federal Volunteer Protection Act of 1997 offers limited immunity for volunteers for certain tort claims, but it is narrow in scope and does not protect volunteers from many governance, employment, fiduciary or regulatory suits. See the Volunteer Protection Act text for reference: https://www.congress.gov/105/plaws/publ19/PLAW-105publ19.pdf

Because immunity is limited, D&O insurance remains necessary to protect volunteer directors from defense costs, settlements and judgments.

How D&O policies treat volunteer directors — core coverage concepts

D&O policies use “Sides” and definitions that determine who is protected and when:

  • Side A (Individual Coverage) — Pays on behalf of individual directors/officers when the organization cannot or will not indemnify them (critical for uninsured nonprofits or when indemnification is barred).
  • Side B (Entity Reimbursement) — Reimburses the nonprofit when it indemnifies directors.
  • Side C (Entity Coverage / Organization Liability) — Covers claims made directly against the nonprofit organization itself (e.g., securities or employment-related suits).

Coverage nuances for volunteers:

  • Many standard nonprofit D&O policies include volunteer directors within the definition of “Insured Person,” but some insurers exclude volunteers or limit their coverage for specific claim types.
  • Indemnification dependence — Volunteers often rely on the nonprofit to indemnify them. Where indemnification is barred by law (e.g., certain regulatory fines) or the nonprofit cannot pay, Side A protection is crucial.
  • Employment Practices Exclusions — If a volunteer is accused in employment-related claims (e.g., harassment), some policies treat those claims differently; standalone Employment Practices Liability (EPLI) or D&O policy endorsements may be needed.
  • Excluded conduct and criminal acts — Intentional illegal acts or fraud are typically excluded; defense costs for breach of fiduciary duty or negligence are usually covered.

State-specific considerations (examples)

  • New York: Large donor litigation and attorney general oversight of charities are common; nonprofits in New York should prioritize Side A limits and defense-cost-inside/outside-limit options to protect volunteers from costly AG investigations.
  • California: Strict employment laws increase EPL exposure; consider EPL add-on coverage for volunteer-involved employment disputes.
  • Illinois / Chicago nonprofits: Frequent grant-related audits and municipal contracting can produce regulatory claims — check for coverage of grant-related investigations and contract-breach suits.

Market pricing and company examples (U.S. market)

Typical premium ranges for small nonprofits vary significantly by size, revenue, claims history, limits and location. Market guidance (industry sources) shows:

Company-specific positioning (examples; market tendencies):

  • Hiscox (small-business / nonprofit focus) — Often competes on lower-premium D&O placements for small organizations; typical small nonprofit quotes may start in the $500–$1,500/year band for basic $1M limits, subject to underwriting. https://www.hiscox.com/small-business-insurance/directors-and-officers-insurance
  • The Hartford — Broad nonprofit product suite; mid-market pricing often in the $700–$2,500/year range for small to mid-size groups, with strong underwriting for volunteer-heavy boards. https://www.thehartford.com/nonprofit-insurance/directors-officers
  • Chubb / AIG / Travelers — Carriers that provide higher-limit and broad-form coverage; often price higher but offer robust Settlement/Defense Options and standalone Side A solutions. Typical small nonprofit placements may run $1,500–$5,000+ depending on complexity and limits.

Note: exact premiums require quotes. The ranges above represent commonly reported market bands; consult your broker or the carriers for bindable pricing.

Coverage comparison — quick reference

Coverage Feature Why it matters for volunteers Practical tip
Side A (Non‑indemnifiable individual) Protects volunteers when the organization cannot indemnify Always request Side A limits equal to the policy aggregate for volunteer-rich boards
Defense costs inside vs outside limits If defense costs erode limits, there may be less left for settlement Prefer defense costs outside the limit where available
Employment Practices Liability (EPL) endorsements Volunteers can be involved in employment claims Add EPL coverage or ensure volunteer directors are explicitly included
Reimbursement for volunteer expenses Pays volunteers’ legal / remediation expenses Confirm reimbursement wording for volunteers
Grant/contract investigations Grant audits can name volunteer board members Obtain endorsements covering investigations related to grant administration

Common coverage gaps and endorsements to consider

  • Side A Difference in Conditions (DIC) — Useful when an organization’s financial condition could impair indemnification.
  • EPL Inclusion for Volunteers — Ensures volunteer directors receive defense and indemnity for employment-related suits.
  • Crime and Fiduciary Extensions — For embezzlement or donor-fund misuse claims that may name board members.
  • Regulatory/Grant Investigation Coverage — Protects volunteers during subpoena/agency probes — vital in states with active AG enforcement (e.g., NY).

See Endorsements Every Nonprofit Board Should Consider in Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance for a detailed rundown.

Practical buying tips for volunteer‑heavy nonprofits (NYC / Los Angeles / Chicago examples)

  • Prepare a clear board roster and governance documents for underwriting: underwriters will ask about volunteer screening, conflicts policies, indemnification bylaws and prior claims.
  • Consider a dedicated Side A or Side A DIC for boards in high‑litigation markets (e.g., New York City nonprofits with large fundraising operations).
  • For California nonprofits with volunteers involved in staff supervision, combine D&O with EPL or add EPL-inclusion endorsements.
  • Small charities in Chicago contracting with municipalities should ensure grant investigation coverage and confirm contract-defense coverage.

For help designing a budget-sensitive program, see: Why Nonprofits Need Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance: Protecting Volunteer Boards on a Budget and Affordable D&O Solutions for Charities and NGOs: Limit Selection and Retention Tips.

Claims examples and lessons

  • Donor challenge naming volunteer board members: Defense costs can quickly exceed $50,000 even for meritless suits — Side A and defense-cost-outside-limit language can prevent volunteers from being personally bankrupted.
  • Grant audit resulting in regulator inquiry: Volunteer treasurers may be subpoenaed; coverage for investigative costs and counsel is crucial.
  • Allegations of breach of fiduciary duty after a program failure: Legal defense, mediation and settlement costs can exceed six figures for larger organizations — higher limits and broad entity-side coverage mitigate organizational and individual risk.

For concrete claim scenarios and takeaways, review: Claims Examples from Nonprofits: Lessons on How Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance Responded.

Action checklist for boards (quick)

  • Confirm volunteer directors are explicitly defined as “Insured Persons.”
  • Obtain Side A protection equal to primary aggregate limits; consider Side A DIC if indemnification risk exists.
  • Add EPL inclusion and grant/investigation endorsements where exposures exist.
  • Get multiple quotes (Hiscox, The Hartford, Chubb, regional carriers) and compare defense-cost handling.
  • Present a clear risk profile to underwriters (governance docs, financials, conflict policies) — see How to Present Your Nonprofit Risk Profile to Secure Better Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability Insurance Terms.

Final note

Volunteer directors are a priceless resource — but without the right D&O structure they face personal exposure that can deter recruitment and impair mission delivery. Evaluate Side A protection, defense-cost wording, EPL inclusion and relevant endorsements tailored to your state and operational profile (e.g., New York fundraising, California employment issues, Illinois grant contracting). Get multiple insurer quotes and work with brokers who specialize in nonprofit D&O placements to secure the best combination of price and coverage.

External references and further reading:

Recommended Articles