on Business Insurance Uncategorized

Coordinating Coverage Between GC, Subcontractor and Owner Policies for HVAC Work

Coordinating insurance coverage on commercial HVAC projects is essential to avoid gaps, duplicate premiums, and costly claim disputes. For HVAC contractors operating in the United States — particularly in large construction hubs like Houston, TX; Los Angeles, CA; and Chicago, IL — clear allocation between the general contractor (GC), subcontractor, and owner policies keeps projects moving and claims predictable. This guide explains the how-to, who-pay-what, common pitfalls, and sample pricing expectations so you can negotiate contracts and certificates with confidence.

Why coordination matters for HVAC work

HVAC installations are frequently high-value, mobile, and installed early in the building envelope sequence. That creates risks for:

  • Material theft, transit damage, and storage losses on-site.
  • Installation-related damage to finished work (water intrusion from piping, ductwork penetrations).
  • Third-party bodily injury and property damage exposures during rigging and rooftop installs.
  • Delays and soft-cost exposures tied to HVAC equipment damage or theft.

Without clear coordination, parties can litigate over fault, or worse, find losses uninsured. The following sections detail typical policy roles and practical coordination steps.

Key policy roles: who typically covers what

  • Owner / Developer — Builders Risk (also called Course of Construction)

    • Primary for damage to the structure and materials intended to become part of the building, if the owner buys the policy (owner-controlled). Builders risk generally insures materials on site, in transit to the site, and sometimes in off-site storage (when endorsed).
    • Typical premium: 0.5%–3% of total completed value, depending on project type and location. (Sources: The Hartford, Travelers)

  • General Contractor (GC) — OCIP/CCIP or project-level wrap

    • On large projects the GC or owner may purchase an OCIP/CCIP (Owner/Contractor Controlled Insurance Program) that consolidates General Liability, Workers’ Comp and sometimes Builders Risk. This simplifies cover but requires tight certificate requirements for subs.
    • GC may also require subcontractors to carry specific limits and endorsements.

  • HVAC Subcontractor — CGL, Inland Marine / Contractors’ Equipment, Tools & Equipment

    • Subcontractor’s Commercial General Liability (CGL) protects against third-party claims (operations, completed operations).
    • Contractors’ Equipment / Inland Marine protects owned and rented tools, rigging, and temporary HVAC units (e.g., temporary rooftop units) while in transit and on multiple sites.
    • Typical annual premiums:
      • HVAC contractor CGL (varies by revenue and claims history): $1,000–$6,000/year for many small-to-mid firms (common mid-market examples shown by brokers such as Insureon).
      • Contractors’ Equipment insurance: ~1%–4% of equipment value annually, depending on deductible and coverage form. (Sources: Insureon, Travelers)

Sources for cost context:

Practical coordination checklist (step-by-step)

  1. Contract review at bid stage

    • Confirm who will purchase builders risk (owner or GC) and whether it includes subcontractor property, transit, and off-site storage.
    • Require a clear insurance exhibit in the subcontract specifying limits, endorsements, and waiver of subrogation.

  2. Define coverage triggers and covered property

    • Clarify whether "materials intended to become part of the work" includes contractor-owned components stored off-site, in transit, or only after delivery.

  3. Certificate of Insurance (COI) and endorsements

    • Subcontractors should supply COIs naming owner and GC as additional insured (for CGL) and showing waiver of subrogation in favor of owner/GC where required.
    • For contractors’ equipment or inland marine, request a memorandum of coverage or policy declaration to confirm scheduled vs. blanket coverage.

  4. Waiver of subrogation and primary/non-contributory wording

    • Owners/GCs commonly require CGL to be “primary and non-contributory” and a waiver of subrogation for Builders Risk. Ensure insurer will provide endorsed wording.

  5. Soft cost/delay endorsements

    • For high-value HVAC equipment (chillers, AHUs), ensure builders risk includes delay in completion/soft costs and expedited replacement coverage if required.

  6. Claims coordination protocol

    • Pre-agree on the claim notification flow: who notifies which carrier, who handles immediate mitigation, and documentation standards (photos, serial numbers, vendor invoices).

Typical allocation examples (realistic scenarios)

  • Small renovation in Houston (owner purchases builders risk): Owner’s builders risk covers materials on-site; HVAC subcontractor keeps contractors’ equipment and tools insured. CGL covers liability. Expect a builders risk premium increase in Gulf Coast locations due to wind/hurricane exposure — often 10%–40% surcharge depending on wind coverage and deductibles. (Market practice; Hurricanes/wind exclusions/endorsements vary by underwriter.)

  • New office tower in Los Angeles with CCIP: The CCIP includes builders risk and wrap GL; HVAC subcontractor removes duplicate coverage and relies on CCIP for property damage to installed work, but must maintain tools and inland marine for transport and off-site storage.

Table: Quick comparison — GC / Owner / Subcontractor coverages for HVAC

Coverage area Owner / Builders Risk GC / CCIP/OCIP HVAC Subcontractor
Physical loss to building & installed HVAC materials Primary (if owner buys) Primary if CCIP Usually not (unless added)
Material in transit / off-site storage Often included if endorsed Included if CCIP Contractors’ Equipment / Inland Marine recommended
Tools, scaffolding, rigging Not usually Not usually Contractors’ Equipment / Tool Floater (recommended)
Third-party BI/PD from operations Not covered Covered (if wrap) CGL (primary)
Soft costs / delay in completion Often available endorsement Included in CCIP if purchased Not usually

Certificates, endorsements and submission requirements

Mandate these items in subcontract exhibits and monitor compliance before allowing work:

  • Additional insured endorsement (CG 20 26 or equivalent) for the GC/owner on the subcontractor’s CGL.
  • Waiver of subrogation on both CGL and workers’ comp.
  • Primary/non-contributory endorsement.
  • Builders risk “included property” endorsement naming subcontractor property, or subcontractor adds inland marine.
  • Schedule of expensive HVAC units (serial numbers, installed location) to the builders risk or inland marine to support valuation and expedite claims.

See also: Certificate and Project Requirements for HVAC Insurers on Construction Sites.

Valuation and settlement options for HVAC equipment

HVAC components can be capital equipment (chillers, large rooftop units) with long replacement lead times. Insist on clear valuation methods:

  • Replacement cost — preferred for new units (no depreciation).
  • Agreed value — schedule high-value equipment on the builders risk or inland marine with an agreed value to avoid undervaluation disputes.
  • Time element/expediting expense — critical when long lead times will cause significant soft costs.

Reference: Valuation Methods and Settlement Options for Damaged HVAC Project Materials.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

  • Gap: owner’s builders risk excludes subcontractor-owned tools — have subcontractor carry inland marine.
  • Overlap: double-covering same exposure leads to premium waste and subrogation battles — use primary/non-contributory and waiver of subrogation.
  • Certificates that don’t match policy language — always request endorsements, not just a COI line-item.
  • Failing to schedule expensive equipment — always list chillers/AHUs on the policy to secure agreed value and expedite claims.

For related implementation guidance, see:

Negotiation tips and sample language to request

  • “Owner/GC shall be additional insured on the Subcontractor’s CGL policy with primary and non-contributory coverage for ongoing and completed operations.”
  • “Waiver of subrogation endorsed in favor of Owner and GC on the CGL, Workers’ Compensation and Builders Risk (as applicable).”
  • “Builders Risk to include off-site storage, transit and agreed value for HVAC equipment scheduled on policy.”

Final considerations — location-specific realities

  • In Houston, TX, add wind/hurricane exposure considerations and inland marine transit protections from long-distance suppliers.
  • In Los Angeles, CA, confirm earthquake exclusions; you may need supplemental coverage or separate equipment floaters for seismic exposure.
  • In Chicago, IL, winter freeze and rooftop snow loading can affect installation exposures; ensure builders risk covers freeze and contractors’ equipment includes extra storage coverage for delays.

By coordinating policies, obtaining required endorsements, and scheduling high-value HVAC equipment properly, owners, GCs, and HVAC subcontractors eliminate ambiguity, reduce premium waste, and speed claims resolution — protecting project schedules and profitability.

External sources

Recommended Articles