Insurance Curator Professional liability insurance (Errors & Omissions, or E&O) is essential for consultants, technology firms, architects, accountants, and many other service providers across the USA. While premium is often the headline number, the true value of a policy lies in several other components that directly affect risk transfer, claims handling, and long-term cost. This guide, focused on the U.S. market (with examples in New York, California and Texas), explains what to evaluate beyond the sticker price and gives practical benchmarking examples you can use when comparing carriers like Hiscox, The Hartford, Chubb and CNA.
Why premium alone is a poor indicator of value
Many buyers choose the lowest premium without checking the policy substance. That’s a mistake because:
- Coverage gaps can expose you to large out-of-pocket costs even with a low premium.
- Limits and retention structure determine how much the insurer pays versus your firm.
- Claims handling quality (defense outside the limit, dedicated claim teams) affects settlement speed and business disruption.
- Exclusions and endorsements can severely narrow protection for common exposures in certain states or professions.
Typical small-business E&O premiums in the U.S. range from about $500 to $1,500 per year for a $1M/$1M policy for low-to-moderate risk professions; higher-risk firms or larger revenue bands often pay $2,000–$10,000+ annually. These ranges align with industry data and market pricing guidance. (Sources: Hiscox, Insureon, NerdWallet.)
- Hiscox and Insureon provide consumer-facing cost guidance and quote tools for small businesses. See these industry references:
Key components to inspect beyond premium
-
Limits and Sublimits
- Verify both aggregate and occurrence limits. A $1M aggregate that erodes with claims may be far less protective than a $1M occurrence limit.
- Watch for sublimits for claim types (e.g., technology-related, cyber, regulatory).
-
Retention / Deductible Structure
- A $1,500 annual premium with a $25,000 retention may be worse than a $2,000 premium with a $5,000 retention.
- Confirm whether retentions apply to defense costs.
-
Defense Provisions
- Defense outside the limit is preferable (defense costs do not reduce the limit available for indemnity).
- Consent to settle clauses protect insureds from unfavorable settlements.
-
Exclusions & Endorsements
- Common exclusions: prior acts, contractual liability, cyber (unless added), punitive damages.
- Tail coverage / extended reporting period options are critical for claims-made policies.
-
Claims Handling & Financial Strength
- Carrier ratings (A.M. Best, S&P) and reported claim response times matter. Choose carriers with strong financials and experienced E&O claims teams.
- Examples: Chubb and CNA are known for underwriting complex professional liability; Hiscox targets small businesses with online quoting.
-
Policy Territory & Regulatory Differences
- State rules (e.g., New York vs. Texas) influence legal exposure and premium. New York and California often have higher jury awards and defense costs, leading to higher premiums.
Location- and profession-specific pricing: what to expect
Pricing varies by state and city due to differing claim frequency/severity and legal environments.
- New York City (higher litigation exposure): expect 10–30% higher premiums than national averages for comparable firms.
- California (large economy, high-value claims): similar uplift, especially in San Francisco and Los Angeles.
- Texas (growing market, mixed exposure): premiums can be close to national averages but spike for specialized professions (e.g., medical consulting).
Below is an illustrative annual premium comparison for a small consulting firm seeking $1M/$1M E&O (approximate ranges):
| Carrier | NYC (1M/1M) | Los Angeles / San Francisco (1M/1M) | Houston / Dallas (1M/1M) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiscox | $600–$1,200 | $550–$1,100 | $500–$1,000 | Strong online SME focus; competitive for lower-risk consultants. |
| The Hartford | $900–$1,800 | $850–$1,700 | $800–$1,600 | Widely used by mid-size firms; comprehensive endorsements available. |
| Chubb | $1,500–$4,000 | $1,400–$3,800 | $1,200–$3,000 | Strong for high-value, complex risks; higher premium but broad coverage. |
| CNA | $1,000–$2,500 | $950–$2,300 | $900–$2,000 | Deep specialty underwriting for many professional classes. |
Note: figures are illustrative based on market rate bands and insurer product positioning; actual quotes depend on revenue, claims history, contract language and service offered. See public pricing guides for reference: https://www.hiscox.com/small-business-insurance/professional-liability-insurance-cost and https://www.insureon.com/professional-liability-insurance/cost.
Practical benchmarking steps (how to compare like-for-like)
- Request full policy forms (not just summary sheets) from each carrier and compare:
- Declarations page, policy form, endorsements, exclusions, and any application statements used to underwrite.
- Standardize quotes to the same:
- Coverage limit (e.g., $1M/$1M), retention amount, claim-made vs. occurrence, and retroactive date.
- Use revenue band benchmarking to see where you fit. Reference: Benchmarking E&O Premiums: Pricing Ranges for Firms by Revenue Band.
- Incorporate claims history: compare premiums for firms with equivalent loss ratios. See: How Claims Experience Affects Your Professional Liability Insurance (Errors & Omissions) Rates.
Checklist: what to ask your broker or carrier before signing
- Can I see the full policy form, all endorsements and the application?
- Are defense costs outside the limit or inside the limit?
- What exactly is excluded (e.g., cyber, punitive damages, contractual liability)?
- Is there a retroactive date and what does it cover?
- How are multi-year claims handled? Is tail coverage available and at what cost?
- What discounts or credits might apply? (See related: Discounts and Credits: How to Lower Professional Liability Insurance (Errors & Omissions) Costs Legally.)
Negotiation levers that reduce total cost (not just premium)
- Improve your risk management: documented controls, client contracts with limited liability, peer reviews — carriers often offer credits.
- Opt for slightly higher retentions if your cashflow permits to lower premium.
- Bundle with other lines (BOP, cyber) for multi-policy discounts.
- Use benchmarking tools to negotiate: see Using Benchmarking Tools to Negotiate Better Professional Liability Insurance (Errors & Omissions) Terms.
Real-world example (illustrative)
A 10-person software consultancy in Manhattan with $2M revenue, clean claims history:
- Hiscox quote for $1M/$1M: ~$1,100/yr with defense inside the limit and limited cyber sublimit.
- The Hartford quote: ~$1,700/yr with defense outside the limit and broader contractual liability.
- Chubb quote: ~$3,200/yr for broader policy wording and higher limits on regulatory defense.
Which is better? If the firm frequently signs tight client contracts requiring robust contractual liability coverage, the higher premium and superior contract wording from The Hartford or Chubb may be justified.
Final checklist before purchase
- Compare full forms — not just price.
- Normalize limits, retentions and retroactive dates.
- Verify carrier financial strength and claims team experience.
- Negotiate endorsements and seek credits tied to real risk controls.
- Use benchmarking resources (internal links above) and multiple carriers to ensure competitive terms.
Choosing an E&O policy is about managing total exposure, not chasing the smallest premium. By benchmarking like-for-like, scrutinizing policy language, and factoring in location-specific legal climate (e.g., New York, California, Texas), you’ll buy protection that actually transfers the risk your business faces.