on Business Insurance Uncategorized

Best Insurance For High-Risk Drivers Comparing Non-Standard Insurers and Their Financial Strength

High-risk drivers — those with DUIs/DWIs, multiple at-fault accidents, suspended licenses, or poor credit — often must shop the non-standard (high-risk) insurance market. Non-standard carriers specialize in higher-risk profiles but vary significantly in price, coverage options, and financial strength. This guide, targeted to drivers in the USA (with city-specific examples for Phoenix, AZ; Houston, TX; and Orlando, FL), compares common non-standard options, shows what to look for in financial ratings, and gives practical steps to reduce costs and move back to standard coverage.

Why financial strength matters for high-risk drivers

When you’re paying a premium that can be two to five times the market average, you want to be sure the insurer will:

  • Pay claims promptly after an accident
  • Stay solvent as your risk profile changes
  • Honor SR-22 filings and state-mandated coverages

Check an insurer’s third-party financial strength rating through AM Best, Standard & Poor’s, or Moody’s. Ratings like A++/A+ (AM Best) signal excellent ability to meet ongoing obligations; lower ratings (B and below) indicate more risk.

Sources and more on insurer ratings:

Typical price impact for high-risk drivers (national context)

  • Standard average annual premium (typical, non-high-risk U.S. driver): roughly $1,200–$1,800 depending on state and limits.
  • High-risk drivers (DUI, multiple at-fault accidents, poor driving record): premiums commonly increase 40%–250%+, depending on offense and state.
  • A single DUI can increase premiums by an estimated ~60%–100% in the first year, with elevated costs for 3–5 years. (See ValuePenguin and NerdWallet summaries below.)

Sources:

Non-standard carriers frequently used by high-risk drivers

The non-standard market includes specialized carriers and many regional players. Commonly-used names include:

  • The General
  • Acceptance Insurance
  • Direct Auto Insurance
  • Dairyland (Progressive subsidiary)
  • Infinity (Kemper/Allstate-affiliated in some places)
  • National General

These insurers differ by state availability, SR-22 support, payment plans, and underwriting rules. Some are niche specialists; others are regional operations with limited footprint.

Real-world premium examples (approximate): Phoenix, Houston, Orlando

Below are example annual premium ranges for a high-risk driver (recent DUI or multiple at-fault accidents) purchasing minimum to moderate state-required coverage. These are illustrative ranges compiled from published insurer rate studies and market summaries — exact quotes vary widely by vehicle, age, driving history, and exact location.

City (State) Typical standard-driver annual premium Non-standard (high-risk) range — annual
Phoenix, AZ $1,100–$1,600 $2,400–$5,500
Houston, TX $1,200–$1,800 $2,800–$6,200
Orlando, FL $1,800–$2,600 $4,000–$8,500

Notes:

  • These ranges reflect market-level observations that high-risk drivers often pay 2–4x the standard premium in many metro areas. For state-level differences and detailed averages, see NerdWallet’s state rate data. (https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/car-insurance-rates-by-state)
  • SR-22 filing fees and monitoring costs (often $25–$100 filing fee plus potential premium surcharges) add upfront expense.

How non-standard insurers compare on key factors

  • Coverage flexibility: Many non-standard carriers focus on minimum liability limits and allow monthly payments; full coverage may be harder to get or require higher deductibles.
  • SR-22 assistance: Most non-standard carriers provide SR-22 filing but check fees and whether they file in your state.
  • Discounts & requalification: Fewer discounts available; however, completing defensive driving courses, telematics, or maintaining continuous coverage can reduce rates over time.
  • Claims service & financial strength: Evaluate AM Best ratings and complaint ratios before choosing a carrier.

Sample comparison table (features, not exhaustive)

Feature The General Acceptance Direct Auto Dairyland
Available in many states Yes Regional (many southern states) Regionally available Select states
Known for flexible underwriting Yes Yes Yes Yes
SR-22 support Yes Yes Yes Yes
Typical target customer High-risk drivers High-risk / non-standard Non-standard drivers Non-standard, DPAs
Financial strength — check AM Best Check AM Best before purchase Check AM Best before purchase Check AM Best before purchase Check AM Best before purchase

Always verify current AM Best or other rating on the insurer’s profile page. Example ratings and company financials change over time (AM Best: https://www.ambest.com/ratings/companies/).

How to choose the best non-standard insurer in your state

  1. Get at least 3–5 real quotes localized to your ZIP code. Rates vary by city block and insurer underwriting rules.
  2. Confirm SR-22 filing and fees. Ask for the exact SR-22 fee and term.
  3. Check financial strength (AM Best) and the NAIC complaint index for the insurer.
  4. Compare coverages, not just price: bodily injury limits, uninsured motorist, towing, and rental coverage matter, especially if you’re paying a premium.
  5. Ask about telematics/usage-based programs — they can deliver meaningful discounts for responsible driving.
  6. If you have poor credit, note that some states restrict credit use in rating. If credit is used, shop insurers known to weigh it less heavily.

Steps to lower premium and transition back to standard coverage

  • Maintain continuous coverage (lapse increases rates and limited insurer options).
  • Complete a state-approved defensive driving course (may be required to remove points).
  • Use telematics/usage-based insurance where available.
  • Improve credit score (where allowed in rating) — slowly reduces premiums.
  • After 3–5 years free of at-fault incidents, shop the standard market aggressively.

For detailed timelines on moving from non-standard to standard coverage and requalification, see:

Special considerations: SR-22, suspended licenses, and short-term needs

  • SR-22: Required in many states after DUI/DWI or serious violations. Expect a filing fee ($25–$100) plus higher premiums for the SR-22 period. (III SR-22 overview: https://www.iii.org/article/what-is-sr-22-and-do-i-need-one)
  • Suspended license/reinstatement: Insurers may cancel your policy for lapses or suspensions. If you need coverage during reinstatement, look for short-term, non-standard providers that explicitly insure drivers with recent suspensions.
  • Short-term coverage: Some non-standard insurers offer monthly policies or flexible payments — useful while rebuilding your record.

More reading on these topics:

Quick checklist before you bind a non-standard policy

  • Verify state filing (SR-22) and cost
  • Confirm AM Best financial strength rating
  • Request written details for coverages, exclusions, and premium change triggers
  • Note cancellation/renewal terms for citations or additional incidents
  • Confirm claims process and local repair/claims network

Final takeaway

Non-standard insurers provide necessary pathways to legally drive after a serious violation, but they are not all the same. Prioritize financial strength (AM Best), SR-22 support, and real localized quotes. In Phoenix, Houston, and Orlando, expect 2–4x the standard premium for high-risk drivers; aggressively pursue telematics, defensive driving, and continuous coverage to bring costs down over 3–5 years.

Further resources used for figures and guidance:

Recommended Articles