Insurance Curator When money is tight but health coverage is essential, picking the right plan becomes a balance of monthly premium, deductible, coverage scope, and legal protections. This guide—focused on U.S. consumers—compares the three most common budget-first choices: catastrophic plans, short-term limited duration insurance (STLDI), and low-premium ACA / marketplace options. It includes realistic price ranges, examples of companies that sell each option, and state/metro-specific guidance (Phoenix, AZ; Houston, TX; Miami, FL). Use this to decide which low-cost path fits your needs and risk tolerance.
Table of contents
- Quick snapshot
- Who should consider each option
- How they compare (table)
- Real-world price ranges and company examples (by city)
- How to pick: questions to ask
- Next steps and sources
Quick snapshot
- Catastrophic plans — Low monthly premiums, extremely high deductibles; only available to people under 30 or with hardship exemptions. Good if you’re young, healthy, and want protection against very large emergencies.
- Short-term plans (STLDI) — Lower premiums than many ACA plans and flexible start dates; however, they are not required to cover essential health benefits (EHBs) and can deny coverage for pre-existing conditions.
- Low-premium ACA / Marketplace options (Bronze, heavy subsidy Silver) — If you qualify for premium tax credits, these can be the best value: low or $0 premiums for eligible households, with consumer protections and coverage for EHBs.
Useful internal links:
- Best Insurance For Health Marketplace Shoppers: How to Pick Silver vs Gold Plans
- Best Insurance For Health for Self-Employed People: Comparing ACA Plans, HSAs and Alternatives
- Best Insurance For Health That Includes Telemedicine and Virtual Care Benefits
Who should consider each option
- Catastrophic
- Eligible: people under 30 or those with a hardship/affordability exemption.
- Ideal if: you want the absolute lowest premium and can cover very high out-of-pocket costs until the deductible is met.
- Short-term (STLDI)
- Eligible: almost anyone (rules depend on state).
- Ideal if: you need immediate temporary coverage (gap coverage when switching jobs) and are comfortable with significant coverage gaps (e.g., no guaranteed prescription or maternity coverage).
- Low-premium ACA / Marketplace plans
- Eligible: everyone on the individual/family market; many qualify for subsidies which make premiums much lower.
- Ideal if: you want guaranteed coverage for pre-existing conditions, maternity, mental health and prescriptions, and want maximum consumer protections.
Head-to-head comparison
| Feature | Catastrophic | Short-Term (STLDI) | Low-Premium ACA (Bronze / subsidized Silver) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium | Very low | Low to moderate | Varies — can be very low with subsidies |
| Deductible | Very high (often $8k+) | Can be high or moderate | Bronze: high; Silver/Gold: lower |
| Covers pre-existing conditions | Yes (if ACA-compliant) | Often no | Yes (guaranteed) |
| Covers essential health benefits (EHBs) | Yes (if ACA plan) | Not required | Yes |
| Maternity, mental health, prescriptions | Typically limited | Often excluded | Included |
| Best use | Young, healthy individuals | Temporary gap coverage | Most consumers who need protections |
| State availability | Nationwide (ACA rules) | Varies — banned/restricted in some states | Nationwide |
Real-world price ranges and company examples (approximate, 2024)
Note: premiums depend heavily on age, zip code, plan metal level, and subsidies. Figures below are approximate national ranges with common company examples. Always run a local quote for exact pricing.
-
Catastrophic plans (available on the ACA Marketplace)
- Typical monthly premium range: $60–$200 for a healthy person under 30 (varies by state and insurer).
- Example companies: Blue Cross Blue Shield subsidiaries, Anthem (where offered), Kaiser Permanente (in markets like California).
- Best for: 20–29 year-olds with minimal medical needs who want a safety net for true emergencies.
- Source on eligibility/details: Healthcare.gov — Catastrophic plans (https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/catastrophic-plans/)
-
Short-term plans (STLDI)
- Typical monthly premium range: $100–$300 for a healthy adult; older or higher-risk ages cost more.
- Example companies: Pivot Health, National General, UnitedHealthcare (historical participation varies by product/market; some large carriers move in/out of STLDI).
- Pros: fast enrollment, low premiums, flexible durations in many states (note: some states restrict term lengths).
- Cons: can exclude pre-existing conditions, maternity, mental health and prescription coverage.
- Sample resource on short-term costs and options: eHealth short-term insurance guide (https://www.ehealthinsurance.com/short-term-health-insurance/short-term-insurance-costs)
-
Low-premium ACA marketplace options (Bronze, subsidized Silver)
- Unsubsidized Bronze monthly premiums (typical range): $200–$600+ depending on age and geography.
- With premium tax credits/subsidies: many households qualify for $0–$50 monthly premium options (varies by income and household size).
- Example insurers by market:
- Phoenix, AZ: Banner Health (Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona), Ambetter (Centene-operated plans).
- Houston, TX: Molina Marketplace plans, Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, Oscar where available.
- Miami, FL: Florida Blue (Blue Cross & Blue Shield of FL), Molina Marketplace, Ambetter.
- For eligibility and subsidy estimates, enroll via Healthcare.gov (federal marketplace) or your state exchange. KFF’s marketplace analysis covers premium and subsidy trends: https://www.kff.org/.
Important note: If your income qualifies for premium tax credits, an ACA plan is often the best low-cost option for comprehensive coverage—many people pay little to nothing monthly.
City-focused examples (how to think about local markets)
- Phoenix, AZ
- Typical low-cost strategy: check Bronze marketplace plans from Banner/BCBS AZ or Ambetter. For immediate short gaps, Pivot Health short-term plans show competitive prices, but check Arizona’s STLDI rules.
- Houston, TX
- Texas has many STLDI products and several low-premium marketplace vendors (Molina, BCBS TX). If you’re low-income and eligible, Marketplace subsidies often trump short-term plans due to better coverage for similar out-of-pocket cost.
- Miami, FL
- Florida has large insurer competition—shop both Marketplace Bronze and subsidy-eligible Silver plans. For short-term needs, National General and private short-term providers may offer temporary lower premiums, but watch for exclusions.
Always run quotes for your exact zip code and age. Many insurer websites and brokers (e.g., eHealth) will show instant local pricing.
How to pick: essential questions before buying
- Can I qualify for premium tax credits (subsidies)? If yes, run Marketplace quotes—ACA plans may end up cheapest and most protective.
- Do I need coverage for pre-existing conditions, maternity, prescriptions, or mental-health care? If yes, avoid short-term plans.
- Am I under 30 or do I have a hardship exemption? If yes, check catastrophic plans for very low premiums.
- Is this coverage temporary (e.g., between jobs) or long-term? Short-term can be OK for short gaps; otherwise choose ACA-compliant coverage.
- What is my acceptable maximum out-of-pocket exposure? Compare deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums, not just premiums.
Quick decision guide
- Choose catastrophic if: you’re under 30, healthy, and want cheap premiums with emergency-only protection.
- Choose short-term if: you need immediate gap coverage, accept exclusions, and plan to transition to ACA or employer coverage soon.
- Choose low-premium ACA if: you want guaranteed comprehensive coverage, have any chronic conditions, or qualify for subsidies that reduce premiums to very low amounts.
Next steps
- Check your subsidy eligibility and get Marketplace quotes at Healthcare.gov.
- Compare local short-term providers (Pivot Health, National General, etc.) for gap pricing if you need immediate start dates.
- If you’re under 30, run catastrophic plan quotes in your Marketplace to compare premium vs deductible trade-offs.
- Read plan documents (Summary of Benefits and Coverage) carefully—focus on out-of-pocket max, network, and covered services.
Sources and further reading
- Healthcare.gov — Catastrophic plans: https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/catastrophic-plans/
- eHealth — Short-term insurance costs and guides: https://www.ehealthinsurance.com/short-term-health-insurance/short-term-insurance-costs
- Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) — Marketplace premium and subsidy analysis and state-level data: https://www.kff.org/
For deeper comparisons, see:
- Best Insurance For Health Marketplace Shoppers: How to Pick Silver vs Gold Plans
- Best Insurance For Health for Self-Employed People: Comparing ACA Plans, HSAs and Alternatives
- Best Insurance For Health That Includes Telemedicine and Virtual Care Benefits
— End of article —