Insurance Curator Choosing the best health insurer comes down to three practical signals: network access, quality scores, and member complaints. This guide compares Anthem with major regional plans (for example: Kaiser Permanente, regional Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliates, and other large state-focused carriers) so you can decide which is most likely to meet your needs.
Quick summary (TL;DR)
- Anthem: Large footprint (many states via Blue Cross licenses), generally broad provider access, plan performance varies by state; good for people who need wide provider choice.
- Major regional plans (e.g., Kaiser, state BCBS affiliates): Often perform better on coordinated-care metrics or local satisfaction where they operate, but availability is limited by geography.
- To choose: verify local network directories, check J.D. Power/NCQA/AM Best ratings for your specific plan, and review NAIC complaint ratios for state-level complaint trends.
How to compare — the three core signals
When comparing any health insurer, use these measures:
-
Network access
- Size: number of in-network doctors/hospitals.
- Breadth vs depth: national PPO networks vs localized HMOs/integrated models.
- Specialist access and out-of-area coverage for travel or seasonal residents.
-
Quality & satisfaction scores
- J.D. Power member satisfaction reports for commercial and Medicare plans.
- NCQA/HEDIS performance, Medicare Star Ratings for Medicare Advantage plans.
- AM Best for financial strength (company stability).
-
Member complaints & regulatory actions
- NAIC complaint ratios (complaints normalized to market share) and state Department of Insurance actions.
- Common complaint themes: claims processing, prior authorizations, provider network accuracy.
For step-by-step guidance on using these metrics to pick a carrier, see: Which Insurer Is Best for You? How to Use JD Power, AM Best, and NAIC Complaint Ratios to Compare Companies.
Anthem: strengths and cautions
Strengths
- Broad network access: Anthem often operates large PPO networks in many states under Blue Cross Blue Shield licenses, which helps when you want access to a wide set of hospitals and specialists.
- Plan variety: Offers PPOs, EPOs, HMO options, and Medicare/Medicaid products in many markets.
- Financial scale: Large national carrier with significant capital and infrastructure.
Cautions
- State-by-state variation: Anthem’s plan performance (care coordination, customer satisfaction, complaint rates) differs significantly by state because many operations are run regionally.
- Member complaints vary: Complaint themes often mirror large national carriers—claims disputes and prior authorization frustrations—so check the NAIC complaint ratio for your state plan.
If you want to compare insurer reputation more broadly (auto/home examples included) and how complaint data is used, this cluster article is a useful reference: Insurer Reputation Report: Rankings, Complaint Trends, and 5 Pros & Cons for GEICO, State Farm, Allstate, Progressive, Lemonade, USAA.
Major regional plans: strengths and cautions
Major regional plans include integrated systems like Kaiser Permanente, state Blue affiliates (e.g., Highmark, CareFirst, Independence Blue Cross), and other regionally focused carriers.
Strengths
- Coordinated care (for integrated models): Systems like Kaiser frequently score highly on preventive care and care coordination because providers and insurers operate under one system.
- Strong local reputation: Regional carriers often focus on community relationships and may have higher satisfaction in the markets they serve.
- Targeted provider networks: Local networks can be deep (many specialists in-region), which can mean better continuity of care.
Cautions
- Limited geographic availability: If you move or travel frequently, the lack of national coverage can be a drawback.
- Network narrowness in some specialties: Some regional plans trade breadth for integration—meaning fewer out-of-network options.
For comparison tips on customer service and complaint data that apply across insurance lines, see: Best Insurance for Customer Service: J.D. Power, AM Best Ratings, and Complaint Data for Allstate, USAA, and Lemonade.
Side-by-side comparison table
| Dimension | Anthem (typical) | Major Regional (e.g., Kaiser / BCBS state plans) |
|---|---|---|
| Network access | Broad national/statewide PPO networks in many markets | Variable — very broad within the region (Kaiser: limited to its service areas) |
| Care model | Separate insurer + provider networks (PPO/EPO/HMO options) | Often integrated (Kaiser) or deep local networks (BCBS affiliates) |
| Quality scores (J.D. Power / NCQA) | Variable by state — check local reports | Often strong locally for integrated plans; BCBS affiliates vary |
| Member complaints (NAIC) | Varies by state; as a large carrier, total volume can be high | Usually lower in tight-knit markets for high-performing regional carriers, but depends on local issues |
| Best for | People needing wide provider choice and multi-state coverage | People seeking coordinated care and high local satisfaction |
How to evaluate Anthem or a regional plan in your ZIP code (quick checklist)
- Search provider directories — confirm your primary care physician and key specialists are in-network. Call the provider’s office to confirm.
- Check plan-level J.D. Power / NCQA / Medicare Star ratings for your state plan and product type.
- Review NAIC complaint ratio and recent state Department of Insurance bulletins for the carrier in your state.
- Confirm prior authorization and formulary policies for services and medications you expect to use.
- Compare price + network — a cheaper premium rarely offsets a narrow network or frequent out-of-network bills.
If you’re also weighing non-health insurers or want broader insurer comparisons using customer satisfaction and financial metrics, these pieces can help build comparative skills:
- Best Insurance Providers 2026: GEICO vs State Farm vs Progressive — Pricing, JD Power Scores, and Pros/Cons
- Best Insurance for Digital-First Buyers: Lemonade vs Progressive — Claims Speed, AI Underwriting, and Privacy Signals
Common member complaint themes (what to watch for)
- Claims delays or denials — check recent complaint narratives for why denials occurred.
- Prior authorization hurdles — likely for imaging, specialty drugs, or elective procedures.
- Provider directory inaccuracies — leads to surprise out-of-network charges.
- Customer service responsiveness — long hold times or unhelpful reps on complex questions.
A deeper look into how complaint data impacts choice can be found here: Which Insurer Is Best for You? How to Use JD Power, AM Best, and NAIC Complaint Ratios to Compare Companies.
Bottom line — which should you pick?
- Choose Anthem if you need broad provider access, live/work in multiple states, or prefer PPO/EPO flexibility.
- Choose a major regional plan (or an integrated system like Kaiser) if you live inside their service area and prioritize coordinated care, usually higher local satisfaction, and streamlined care management.
Before enrolling, confirm network participation and review plan-level ratings and complaint trends in your state. If you want help interpreting J.D. Power or complaint data when comparing two specific plans, I can walk through a side-by-side evaluation for your ZIP code and plan options.