on Business Insurance Uncategorized

Reservation of Rights, Coverage Disputes and Working with Defense Counsel in Hospitality Claims

Restaurants, bars, hotels and other hospitality operations face elevated liability and property exposures. When a claim arises in high-liability markets such as New York City, Los Angeles, or Miami, the interplay between an insurer’s reservation of rights (ROR), coverage disputes, and selection/payment of defense counsel will determine both litigation outcomes and the insured’s ultimate costs. This article — aimed at risk managers, claims professionals, brokers and restaurant/hotel owners in the USA — explains practical steps, cost expectations, and tactical considerations for resolving coverage friction quickly and preserving recovery opportunities.

Key concepts: reservation of rights, denial, non-waiver agreements

  • Reservation of Rights (ROR): A letter from the insurer accepting defense (or investigation) but reserving the right to later deny coverage based on specific policy terms, exclusions, or facts discovered during investigation.
  • Denial: A formal refusal to provide coverage or defense. May trigger immediate legal action by the insured.
  • Non-Waiver Agreement: A short-term contract where insurer and insured agree that investigation proceeds without prejudice while coverage is determined.

Understanding these distinctions is essential: an ROR preserves insurer defenses while protecting the insurer’s right to withdraw later; a denial immediately forces the insured to either defend itself or seek declaratory relief.

Why hospitality claims frequently trigger RORs

Hospitality claims often involve multiple potential coverage issues:

  • Liquor liability/exclusion (dram shop laws in New York, California, Florida)
  • Employee acts (intentional acts exclusions)
  • Assault & battery exclusions in nightclubs
  • Food-borne illness (product liability vs. CGL vs. product contamination endorsements)
  • Business interruption tied to civil authority, viruses, or equipment failure

Because these facts implicate exclusions or multiple policies (general liability, liquor liability, BOP, umbrella/excess), carriers commonly issue RORs early to avoid waiving defenses while investigations proceed.

Typical insurer behavior and timelines

  • Initial contact/FNOL: 24–72 hours
  • Coverage evaluation and ROR/non-waiver: within 7–14 days of notice (so insurers preserve defenses)
  • Appointment of defense counsel: 7–21 days after ROR (can be immediate if urgent)
  • Coverage denial (if any): 30–90 days if facts indicate exclusion

Insurers rely on early RORs to avoid estoppel; insureds should treat RORs seriously but not as final determinations.

Working with defense counsel: selection, billing and conflicts

When an insurer agrees to defend under an ROR, the insured may be exposed to a future claim for reimbursement or denied coverage for indemnity. How defense counsel is selected and how conflicts are handled matters.

  • Panel counsel vs. independent counsel

    • Panel counsel (selected by carrier): cost-efficient, consistent billing guidelines, and familiarity with carrier expectations.
    • Independent or Cumis counsel (California) / conflict counsel (more broadly): required when the insurer’s interests materially conflict with the insured’s (e.g., insurer reserves rights that could prejudice indemnity).

  • Billing expectations (typical ranges, U.S. metro market)

    • New York City: partners $600–1,200/hr; senior associates $300–600/hr; defense specialists vary by firm and practice.
    • Los Angeles: partners $500–900/hr; associates $250–500/hr.
    • Chicago: partners $450–800/hr; associates $225–450/hr.

These are market ranges for outside counsel in major U.S. cities; actual rates vary by firm and complexity. For reference and market cost context see industry cost analyses from insurers and small-business platforms: Insureon (restaurant insurance pricing) and Hiscox (small-business insurance cost guides).
Sources: https://www.insureon.com/restaurant-insurance/, https://www.hiscox.com/small-business-insurance/cost

Practical billing controls to negotiate up-front

  • Hourly caps for partners/associates
  • Task-based billing (caps for depositions, motion practice)
  • Monthly budget & early-warning for overruns
  • E-billing and line-item time detail

When a reservation of rights leads to a coverage dispute

If an insurer later denies coverage, typical insured responses:

  • Seek defense cost allocation if allegations include both covered and uncovered claims (e.g., assault plus negligence)
  • Demand insurer-provided independent counsel where conflict exists (state law dependent)
  • File a declaratory judgment action against the insurer (or request one by insurer)
  • Move for estoppel if carrier’s conduct was prejudicial (late denials after long defense funding)

Insurance carriers and insureds should document the investigative timeline, key witness statements, EBM (electronic business records) and mitigation steps to support or rebut coverage positions.

Financial expectations: what coverage fights cost hospitality businesses

  • Small independent restaurant (NYC, 50–150 seats): typical annual BOP/CGL premium ranges roughly $5,000–$20,000 depending on payroll, liquor exposure and property value. Specialty insurers (Chubb, The Hartford, Travelers, CNA, Hiscox) offer products for restaurants with varying pricing and endorsements. Estimates from market cost surveys and program quotes indicate substantial variability; always obtain competitive quotes for accurate budgeting. See market guidance: https://www.insureon.com/restaurant-insurance/, https://www.hiscox.com/small-business-insurance/cost
  • A single litigated incident involving serious injury can rapidly exceed policy limits; defense billing alone for complex cases (dispositive motions, multiple depositions, expert reports) can reach $75,000–$250,000 before indemnity exposure is considered in large urban markets (NYC/LA).

Documentation defenders and adjusters will demand

Insurers will expect thorough proof of loss and mitigation documentation. Prepare:

  • Incident reports, surveillance, and witness statements
  • Employee training logs (alcohol service training, food safety certifications)
  • Vendor invoices and maintenance records (for equipment failures)
  • Sales records, POS data, and financial statements for lost profits claims

See related guidance on documentation: Salvage, Mitigation and Proof of Loss: Documentation Insurers Will Demand from Restaurants

Coordination across primary and excess carriers

Hospitality claims frequently involve multiple insurers (primary, excess, liquor liability carriers). Prompt coordination is essential:

  • Identify all potentially available policies and limits
  • Notify primary carrier first; follow policy notice terms strictly
  • If primary pays defense under reservation and excess denies, obtain written positions early and consider declaratory relief

For detailed coordination tactics: Coordinating Multiple Insurers: Primary vs Excess Coverage Issues in Hospitality Claims

Avoiding common pitfalls that lead to denials or litigation

  • Late notice: many denials are based on alleged late notice — provide FNOL promptly.
  • Poor record-keeping: missing training logs or maintenance invoices weakens the insured’s position.
  • Inadequate cooperation: insurers may assert breach of cooperation clauses if the insured obstructs defense.
  • Failure to separate covered/uncovered claims: early allocation analysis prevents insurer/insured fights later.

For a list of frequent coverage errors and how to prevent them, see: Common Coverage Pitfalls in Hospitality Claims and How to Avoid Denials

Checklist: immediate steps after receiving an ROR in a hospitality claim

  • Read the ROR closely; note specific policy clauses cited and deadlines.
  • Preserve all evidence (video, receipts, logs) and provide copies to insurer and counsel.
  • Confirm who controls defense counsel selection and whether conflict counsel is required.
  • Seek a non-waiver agreement if immediate facts are unsettled.
  • Budget for defense costs and notify broker if excess carriers may be implicated.
  • Consider early mediation if liability facts are strong and limits are at risk.

Conclusion

Reservation of rights letters are common in hospitality claims because of multiple, overlapping exposures (liquor, assault, food contamination, employee acts). Timely documentation, early coordination among carriers, and careful counsel-selection and billing controls reduce the risk that a coverage fight will turn into a catastrophic financial event for a restaurant or hotel. For hands-on claim handling workflows and post-claim program protection, consult your broker and review best practices such as those detailed in our operational guides: Insurance Claims Handling for Hospitality Incidents: From First Notice to Final Settlement.

External references

Recommended Articles