on Business Insurance Uncategorized

Workers’ Comp, CGL and Property Differences Between Residential and Commercial HVAC Work

Content pillar: Residential vs Commercial HVAC Insurance Needs
Location focus: Houston, Texas — implications apply across U.S. metros

Commercial-intent summary: If you run an HVAC contracting business in Houston and are bidding both residential service calls and commercial retrofit projects, insurance strategy matters. This article compares Workers’ Compensation (WC), Commercial General Liability (CGL), and Property coverage differences between residential and commercial HVAC work, gives realistic cost ranges from major carriers, and explains how to price insurance into bids and meet contract requirements.

Why residential vs commercial changes insurance needs

Residential HVAC jobs are usually smaller‑scale, lower payroll per job, shorter durations, and lower third‑party exposure (single‑family home, fewer subcontractors). Commercial projects (office buildings, warehouses, tenant improvements, large RTUs, chilled‑water systems) increase exposures: larger job values, multiple general contractors, tenant risk, complex rigging, and required additional insured endorsements and higher limits. These risks affect WC, CGL, and Property premiums differently.

1) Workers’ Compensation: payroll, classifications and experience mod

Residential vs commercial implications

  • Residential crews often perform service calls and small installs with fewer workers on-site at a time — lower payroll exposure per job but frequent travel.
  • Commercial jobs tend to have larger crews, longer project durations, and increased use of subcontractors and rigging equipment — raising payroll exposure and potential severity of workplace injuries.

Key underwriting drivers

  • Payroll size and mix: WC premium = payroll × class rate × experience modification (mod). Larger payroll ⇒ larger absolute premium.
  • Class codes: HVAC technician class codes (varies by state) are applied whether you do residential or commercial; however, commercial tasks (roof work, rooftop unit installs) may attract higher ancillary class codes or endorsements.
  • Experience mod: Claims on commercial projects (falls from roofs, crane incidents) can increase mod and premium.

Typical cost examples (Houston, TX)

  • Small residential-only HVAC shop (2–4 employees, $150k annual payroll): WC premiums often run roughly $4,000–$10,000/year depending on experience mod and exact duties.
  • Commercial-focused contractor (10+ employees, $800k+ payroll): WC premiums commonly reach $30,000–$100,000+/year.

Sources for WC underwriting basics and cost drivers: Insureon and Next Insurance discuss payroll/mod impacts — see:

2) Commercial General Liability (CGL): limits, endorsements, and compliance

How coverage differs

  • Residential jobs often accept standard CGL with $1M per occurrence / $2M aggregate and include coverage for bodily injury/property damage to customers and third parties.
  • Commercial clients (GCs, building owners) frequently require higher limits—commonly $2M/$4M or more—and specific endorsements:
    • Additional Insured (CG 20 10/20 37 or equivalents)
    • Waiver of Subrogation
    • Primary and Non‑contributory wording
    • Completed operations extensions for long-tail liability tied to installations

Why commercial premiums rise

  • Higher limits increase premium significantly.
  • Additional insured endorsements and primary/non‑contributory wording may raise rates.
  • Commercial exposure increases likelihood of larger losses (e.g., HVAC leaks leading to tenant business interruption, rooftop equipment falls hitting pedestrians).

Sample CGL pricing from major providers (Houston market)

Table — Typical CGL limits and Houston sample annual cost ranges

Work Type Typical Required Limits Common Endorsements Houston sample annual cost*
Residential service/maintenance $1M/$2M None or standard $400–$1,200
Residential installs (bigger jobs) $1M/$2M Completed ops $600–$1,800
Commercial small projects $1M/$2M or $2M/$4M Additional insured, Waiver of subrogation $1,200–$6,000
Commercial large/GC projects $2M/$4M+ Primary/non-contrib, higher limits $3,000–$15,000+

*Ranges illustrative; final quotes depend on loss history, payroll, contract language, and carrier.

3) Property insurance: tools, equipment, builders risk and operations property

Residential exposures

  • Tools, service trucks, and small on‑site materials—common solution: Inland Marine / Contractors’ Equipment floater plus Business Personal Property for shop contents.
  • Typical tool insurance: scheduled tools limit $10k–$50k for small outfits.

Commercial exposures

  • On‑site staging of expensive mechanical equipment (large rooftop units, boilers), longer storage on site, and higher replacement values drive need for:
    • Builder’s Risk or Course of Construction coverage (owner or contractor, depending on contract)
    • Installation Floater (covers equipment in transit and during installation)
    • Higher Scheduled Equipment limits and rental reimbursement for downed equipment

Typical property/floaters cost (Houston)

  • Inland Marine/Tool floater: $300–$2,000/year depending on limits and theft/transport exposures.
  • Installation floater/Builder’s Risk premiums are project-specific; typical builder’s risk premium can be 0.1%–1.0% of completed value depending on scope and controls.

4) Other policies and endorsements to consider for commercial HVAC work

  • Pollution Liability: HVAC projects involving refrigerants and oils — commercial jobs may require it.
  • Professional/Design Liability: Commercial mechanical design or engineering work may trigger E&O claims.
  • Commercial Auto & Hired/Non‑Owned Auto: higher commercial driving exposures on large projects.
  • Umbrella/Excess Liability: cost‑effective way to meet GC limit demands (usually starts around $1M excess).

Practical contracting and bidding tips (Houston examples)

  • Always confirm client-required limits and endorsements before bidding. Many Houston school districts or healthcare facilities require specific wording and $2M–$10M limits.
  • When bidding a commercial job that requires additional insured and primary/non‑contributory language, add 2–6% of your estimated insurance cost into the bid to cover increased premiums and administrative fees.
  • If your business is residential‑heavy and you consider expanding to commercial, get a producer/broker quote on a hypothetical commercial job to model the premium impact — see “When a Residential HVAC Company Should Expand Coverage to Enter Commercial Work” for guidance: When a Residential HVAC Company Should Expand Coverage to Enter Commercial Work

Examples of real‑world carrier pricing and resources

How to operationalize the differences

  • Maintain separate job cost models for residential and commercial projects that include estimated incremental insurance costs, administrative COI fees, and potential increases in WC exposure.
  • Use written subcontractor agreements requiring COIs and hold‑harmless/indemnity terms; verify subcontractor limits and additional insured status.
  • Track project payroll and class codes closely and ask your broker for a pre-bid certificate template for each project type.

Internal resources to deepen planning and compliance

Bottom line

  • Residential HVAC work tends to demand lower absolute insurance spend but still requires proper CGL, WC, and tools coverage.
  • Commercial HVAC dramatically increases required limits, endorsements, and potential claims severity — plan for larger WC exposure, higher CGL limits and additional insured/primary wording, and project‑specific property/installation coverages.
  • In Houston and other major U.S. markets, get carrier quotes specific to each project type before bidding; include insurance delta in your overhead and bid markup to avoid surprise premiums or contract noncompliance.

For contractor-specific sample pricing, policy details, or a commercial pre‑bid insurance checklist, consult your broker and review carrier pages above to get tailored quotes for Houston operations.

Recommended Articles